Not always: play should suit the work, the people it serves, the team’s values, and clear safety and respect boundaries.
If you manage a serious, customer-facing, regulated, or high-pressure setting, you can still make room for energy and imagination without asking everyone to perform cheerfulness.
What does appropriate Play look like?
In FISH!, Play is a way of bringing curiosity, creativity, and useful energy to the work, not a requirement to organize games or jokes. A hospital team might test a simpler handoff, a warehouse crew might redesign a frustrating route, and a trainer might invite a fresh example instead of repeating the usual script. These choices can make work more engaging while improving service, learning, or problem solving.
The key is the playing field: what is welcome, what is out of bounds, and where people have room to try, adjust, and learn. Humor can belong there when it includes people and lifts the moment; teasing, embarrassment, unsafe shortcuts, or disruption do not.
How can a team decide?
A useful check begins when someone pauses and asks, “Who am I being while I’m doing this?” Choosing an attitude of curiosity, respect, and helpfulness makes it easier to notice whether an idea serves the situation or merely entertains the person proposing it. That ongoing choice matters especially after a failed experiment, a tense customer interaction, or a colleague’s hesitation: acknowledge what happened, reset, and decide how to proceed without forcing positivity.
Then use the rest of the FISH! lens: Does the idea help you Be There for others? Could it Make Their Day without putting anyone on the spot? Does it preserve responsibilities, inclusion, and safety?
Try one small experiment this week. Define the non-negotiables with the team, invite a low-risk improvement, and review what people learned rather than judging whether the attempt looked fun. Play is working when it gives people more curiosity and capability, not when it asks them to ignore the work or each other.
Questions like this one, and many more about employee wellbeing, are explored in the FISH! Philosophy upgraded trial, which gives your team 30 days of access to the FISH! film and its digital guides.