Company values are working when they guide real decisions, especially under pressure, and when employees and customers can feel the difference. Compare what the organization says with what it rewards, measures, and does.

A values poster is evidence of intention, not impact. Look at hiring, promotion, recognition, workload decisions, customer recovery, and responses to mistakes. If “care” is a stated value but people are punished for taking time to explain a complex issue, the system is teaching a different lesson.

What signs should leaders look for?

When teams practice Make Their Day, a value becomes an observable effect: someone leaves an interaction feeling noticed, respected, or better able to continue. Ask employees for examples of times a value helped them make a decision. A strong example includes the choice, the action, and who benefited.

Suppose a team says it values respect. An employee might describe slowing down a conversation with a confused customer, arranging a better handoff, and checking that the customer knew what would happen next. Another example might involve thanking a colleague whose behind-the-scenes work prevented a problem. These moments show how a value travels through daily work.

Combine stories with employee and customer feedback and operating results. No single metric proves that a value is alive. Stories show meaning, surveys show experience, and results show whether the practice is helping the work.

How can values show up in daily decisions?

Look for:

  • Decisions that refer to values when tradeoffs are difficult.
  • Recognition tied to behaviors rather than personality or favoritism.
  • Customer comments that describe the intended experience.
  • Employees who can explain what the values mean in their role.
  • Leaders holding themselves to the same standard as everyone else.

Review the evidence regularly, then change a system when it contradicts the value.

Questions like this one, and many more about trust and leadership, are explored in the FISH! Philosophy upgraded trial, which gives your team 30 days of access to the FISH! film and its digital guides.

Related questions